Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

 | 2am PDT | 5am EDT | 09:00 UTC | 10:00 BST | 11:00 CEST | 12:00 EEST | 14:30 IST | 17:00 CST | 18:00 JST |


Web Conference:

https://thorsten-heinze-telefonica-de.webex.com/thorsten-heinze-telefonica-de/j.php?MTID=m849236edb092dffd10071725f5b8839f 

Invited:

(please feel free to correct and update your names (wink) Thank you very much!!!) 

Discussion items

TimeItemWhoNotes
00:00chair topic 
no update 

00:05

Admin

Next meetings

2021-07-14: Martin Skorupski

2021-07-21: Martin Skorupski

2021-07-28: Martin Skorupski

2021-08-04: Martin Skorupski

00:05

RMON - EthernetContainer #45

MacInterface #24

@Andreas Lattoch

Thorsten Heinze 

Are there RMON counters to be moved from MacInterface to EthernetContainer?

Editorial modification on the proposal - no change of objective or content.


Decision: proposal is approved.

00:10MacInterface #36

Deleting MacInterfaceConfiguration::InterfaceIsOn


Decision: proposal is approved.

00:13MacInterface #37

Deleting MacInterfaceConfiguration::performanceMonitoringIsOn


Decision: proposal is approved.

00:15HybridMwStructure #16

ObjectCreationNotification::_objectIdRef should be IsReadOnly==1


Decision: proposal is approved.

00:18HybridMwStructure #17

ObjectDeletionNotification::_objectIdRef should be IsReadOnly==1


Decision: proposal is approved.

00:21HybridMwStructure #19

Object References in CurrentPerformance to be deleted


Decision: proposal is approved.

00:24HybridMwStructure #20

Object References in CurrentPerformance to be deleted


Decision: proposal is approved.





00:25MacContainer #26

maximum-frame-size might have discrete value ranges

kindly request to vendors,

  • Is the maximum-frame-size attribute supported at all
    • Answer yes!
  • with discrete values?
    • Answer yes! - but also as continuous range in other cases.
  • for Tuesday June-29th 


Decision: proposal is approved.

00:30MacContainer #38

link-loss-forwarding-delay might have discrete values

kindly request to vendors,

  • Is the link-loss-forwarding-delay attribute supported at all
    • Answer yes (for some vendors)
  • with discrete values?
  • for Tuesday June-29th 


Decision: proposal is approved.

00:35AirInterface #46Thorsten Heinze

interfaceStatus, PowerIsUp, LinkIsUp, OperationalState and AdministrativeState at the LTP

Please have a look - this is the last open in AirInterface


radio-power-is-up: not supported by many of the vendors (as an operational attribute): AirInterface #52

interface-status: vendors need to double check if only enabled/disabled is supported, or the entire IETF operational status values; if only enabled/disabled is supported, the attribute could be deleted and operational-state of the LTP could be used instead

Discussion to be continued.



End of the meeting









00:15Synchronization

@Alexander Wenk

@Prathiba

Current status:

  • UML-to-yang - synch_Pac - to generate a yang
  • create a workspace - with new - specify/augmentation to the core-model-1.4
  • there is a need to create a "new" UML-project

First try to generate yang model-

  • some manually modification
    • stereotype "experiment" - update of OpenModelProfile
    • then some issues found by pyang
      • duplicate of attributes - same attribute but different description
      • issue on a class which is not required - maybe we simply remove it from yang generation
      • feedback by Thorsten - UML/YANG header info missing

See feedback from Kam:

Info from 2021-07-06:

  • Alexander is going to create issues based on the feedback by vendors
00:00Mediator Instance Manager

Pre- Discussion happened yesterday 

  • info send by Thorsten on Monday 2021-05-17
  • in addition Thorsten will send the "background discussion slide"....

Mediator Instance Manager 

  • What is the protocol? NETCONF or REST or RESTCONF or ...
    • Working Assumption:  not decided
    • SIAE would like to decide based on efforts after analysis. 
    • UML include the "service" - but not the operational and maintenance layer
    • YAML (OpenAPI3) → UML (papyrus) → YANG → 

2021-05-25

  • Any questions?
    • no questions

2021-06-16

  • please see "App layer on top of the SDN controller" above.

Action items