1. Pages
2. …
3. OIMT
4. IISOMI
5. IISOMI Minutes

2022-07-15 IISOMI Meeting Minutes

15 Jul 2022 Leader: Bernd/Kam; (Not available: Scott)

22 Jul 2022 Leader: Scott; (Not available: Bernd)

29 Jul 2022 Leader: Cancel; (IETF 114 week Not available: Scott, Italo, Nigel, Andrea)

05 Aug 2022 Leader: Kam; (Not available: Nigel)

12 Aug 2022 Leader: TBD; (Not available: Nigel, Italo)

19 Aug 2022 Leader: TBD; (Not available: Nigel, Italo)

26 Aug 2022 Leader: Nigel; (Not available: Kam, Italo)

IISOMI Action Items done or past due

• Scott Mansfield Andrea Mazzini  24 Jun 2022 Discuss xmi2yang tooling regarding to the translation of UML stereotype «Cond» (condition) into (if/when) feature statements.
  • Refreshed from 24 Jun 2022 to 26 Aug 2022 

• • Scott Mansfield Andrea Mazzini  26 Aug 2022 Discuss xmi2yang tooling regarding to the translation of UML stereotype «Cond» (condition) into (if/when) feature statements

• Hing-Kam Lam Bernd Zeuner  01 Jul 2022 Need to clean up other pages, such as Guidelines and Tooling Discussion Items and move material to IISOMI Discussions
  • Cleaned-up performed, reviewed and agreed as follows:
    • #1 (Yang mapping of UML construct names) has been moved to → Closed Discussed Items "Mapping of UML construct names in UML Comment"
    • #2 (Abstractions: How to dump the properties.) has been moved to → Gendoc related items "Abstractions: How to dump the properties". 
    • #3 (Abstractions: The stereotype "Cond" is not managed) is considered as part of  the UML-YANG Mapping Guidelines related items "Use of Feature/Condition"
    • #4 (Yang Identity lost in yang2oas mapping) has been moved to → YANG-OAM Mapping related items "Yang Identity Lost in yang2oas"
    • #5 (Tool handling of Inter-module identities) has been moved to → UML-YANG Mapping Guidelines related items "Tool handling of Inter-module Identities"
  • This action item is done.
• Hing-Kam Lam Bernd Zeuner  15 Jul 2022 Assess 2022-05-27 IISOMI Meeting Minutes and extract all discussion items into IISOMI Discussions as appropriate
  • This action item is done. 

IB

References

• IISOMI Action Items: Italo Busi 01 Jul 2022 Coding of target path: Provide an update to the diagram and propose text for the mapping guidelines. (see Coding of target path)
• IISOMI Discussions: Coding of target path

Discussion: 15 Jul 2022 

• Discuss and recap the inconsistency among the following 3 specifications related to the «Specify» stereotype:
  • In the UML Guideline, Figure 5.30: ClassB must be abstract. 
  • In TAPI, ClassB is concrete
  • In the UML2YANG Guideline, in some diagrams the class is abstract, but the text implies concrete (container). 
• How to resolve the inconsistency?
  • Remain open.
    • Need to evaluate the impact on TAPI if it is going to follow the UML Guideline.
    • Need to investigate the impact on the behaviour of the different forks of the mapping tools.

Plan

• 22 Jul 2022 
  • Check if there needs any update to the three guideline documents due to the Closed Discussion Items.
• 29 Jul 2022
• 05 Aug 2022 
  •  Coding of target path
• 12 Aug 2022 
• 19 Aug 2022 

• Clean-up or disposition of the wiki page Versions of UML Models and Modeling Tools (Overview)