Child pages
  • 2020-06-12 IISOMI Meeting minutes
Skip to end of metadata
Go to start of metadata

Date

| 6am PDT | 9am EDT | 13:00 UTC | 15:00 CEST | 

Zoom: https://www.zoom.us/j/853336915

Attendees

Agenda

  • Administrative
    • Call plan: schedule, leader, topics
  • Check status of suggested action for resolving the G.8052.1 UML to Yang mapping issues (not covered)
    • Object key with the "config false"; see Issues 1 & 3 in the "itut-g-8052dot-1@2020-01-27_modified.yang" file (not covered)
    • Missing typedef, such as alarm-severity-code, csf-config, etc.; see "Issue 4" in the "itut-g-8052dot-1@2020-01-27_modified.yang" file (not covered)
  • Eagle UML->Yang tool
  • Discuss UUID and Local Id
    • Alternatives include id injection and UUID only for all classes
  •  Papyrus guidelines
    • Which Papyrus version is recommended?
    • URL of the version of Papyrus in the Installation section of the Papyrus guidelines 
  • UML modeling guidelines
    • The "Reference" stereotype
  • AOB

Discussion items

Time

Item

Who

Notes

3 minCall planAll

 Leader Nigel Davis

 Leader Hing-Kam Lam

 Leader Italo Busi (Bernd & Andrea on vacation)

 Leader Bernd Zeuner

10 min

Eagle YML → Yang: Improved release process for tooling

All

Need to identify the appropriate version of the tool for deliverable generation. Use a semi-formal release process. Latest version on git may not be the best to use for a release.

Andrea MazziniNigel Davis , Arturo MayoralXing Zhao  Determine process.

4 minCheck pending Merge pull request#14

Karthik SethuramanDetermine approach to progress this pull request: Merge pull request#14

1 minUUID and Local Id
Deferred to next call
40 minPapyrus version & URL for installation

Which version of Papyrus is recommended

  • Survey result
    • 2018-09: Bernd, Italo, Kam, Scott, Nigel
    • 2019-09: Andrea, Nigel
    • 2020-03: ?Karthik?
  • Need recommendation from Karthik
  • Nigel: One can open/edit a model, which was created by a newer version of Papyrus. 

Updating the installation part of the Papyrus Guidelines; how to deal with changed URLs for the downloads

  • The URL in the current guideline document is out of date already. 
  • Agreed approach:
    • The guideline document points to a table in the IISOMI wiki, there is the table that shows the URLs of the available Eclipse/Papyrus versions.
      • Bernd ZeunerTo provide the table of Eclipse/Papyrus versions and URLs

Guideline on the Reference stereotype

  • Italo commented that the currect specification of the Reference stereotype (Section 6.5.4 "Reference Property") in the modeling guideline (TR-514 v1.3) is not clear/complete enough.
    • Italo Busi  To provide the cases that couldn't be clearly specified per the current guidelines.
2 minAgenda of next callAll

Call plan for

  • Eagle UML->Yang tool
  • Check status of suggested action for resolving the G.8052.1 UML to Yang mapping issues (See 2020-05-22 IISOMI Meeting minutes)
    • Object key with the "config false"; see Issues 1 & 3 in the "itut-g-8052dot-1@2020-01-27_modified.yang" file (See )
    • Missing typedef, such as alarm-severity-code, csf-config, etc.; see "Issue 4" in the "itut-g-8052dot-1@2020-01-27_modified.yang" file
  • Discuss UUID and Local Id
  • Papyrus version & URL for installation 
  • Guideline on the Reference stereotype
  • UML-YANG mapping
    • Comments from Italo on the G.8052.1 yang
0 minAOBAllNone

Action items